Brownsburg tied with Plainfield 2-2 at Lucas Oil Stadium on Saturday.
After going down 1-0 in the second half, Brownsburg maintained steady pressure for the majority of the second half.
Even so, Plainfield was able to extend their lead.
With nine minutes to go, Noah Yohannes scored on his second penalty kick of the night to bring Brownsburg within one.
Delijah N'gbesso scored a beautiful goal with only two and a half mintues remaining to tie it up.
The Bulldogs are now 2-3-3 and play at Fishers on Tuesday.